The Fairfax County Public Schools School Board has an opportunity to make a meaningful research-based improvement to the health and well-being of our county’s students. But will they or will they whiff? I am concerned, based on the current approach, that this Board is allowing what should be a fairly straightforward policy question to become an exercise in avoiding difficult decisions, counting meaningless survey responses, and overstating modest costs. It appears they are choosing to whiff.

Yes, we all recognize that changing school start times is complicated. Transportation, childcare, athletics, employee schedules, and family routines all matter to students, staff, and parents. No solution that will satisfy everyone and the best decision will often leave many less than fully satisfied - that is the nature of these types of decisions, it’s why we need political leaders not followers.

This is why we elect a School Board. It is why we compensate school board members forty-eight thousand dollars ($48,000) per year for their time on these matters. We elect and compensate these people to work on the hard problems and make the difficult decisions - and they appear to want to avoid the hard and difficult part at the expense of what is best for Fairfax County children.

The Board’s responsibility is not simply to identify the most popular option. It is to make informed policy decisions in the best interests of students and residents of Fairfax County.

A Survey Is Not a Substitute for Leadership

FCPS has and is devoting considerable attention to surveying families, students, and staff about their preferred schedules. Community input can be useful, and the Board should take the time to understand how proposed changes affect people.

But asking respondents which option they prefer is not the same as asking which option best serves the long-term interests of students. In fact, conducting online surveys isn’t necessarily a good way to the type of valuable input needed. Targeted surveys, properly conducted focus groups, and public data analysis are all better candidates to inform a deliberative political body.

Most parents are not transportation planners, sleep researchers, or school-system budget experts. Nor should they have to be. Parents understandably evaluate proposals based on their own children’s schedules, work obligations, and immediate circumstances.

That perspective is valuable. It is also incomplete.

The earlier FCPS survey produced no clear overall majority for a single option. Response rates and self-selection raise legitimate questions about whether the results represent the broader community. Yet these preferences appear to be receiving extraordinary weight in the discussion.

If the Board’s approach is simply to adopt whichever option receives the most responses, why have an elected School Board at all? Why not decide every difficult education policy question through an online poll?

Representative government exists precisely because good decisions require balancing competing interests, evaluating technical evidence, and exercising judgment beyond what is immediately well understood by or popular with the public.

FCPS School Board members were elected to do that work. They should listen to constituents, consult experts, explain their reasoning, and ultimately take responsibility for their decisions. It is not their job to simply do the most popular (or least unpopular) thing - it is to figure out the right thing and explain that decision to the public they represent.

Also, it’s worth noting that putting out a survey for two weeks during a holiday does not exactly demonstrate a serious effort to maximize the response rate.

Let’s Keep the Costs in Perspective

I am also bothered by the way cost has entered this discussion.

Estimates for the proposed changes are in the neighborhood of $1.6 million to $1.8 million annually. For the average person that is real money and political leaders should recognize that and taxpayers deserve accountability for every dollar.

But reason must prevail and the reality is that FCPS operates on an annual budget of approximately $4.1 billion.

Even at $1.8 million, we are talking about roughly 0.045% of the operating budget, that is less than five-hundredths of one percent. To put those numbers in perspective, the median Fairfax County married household with school age children has a household income of $192,000 and we are debating whether to spend $90 a year to benefit our children’s education. This isn’t even a serious point of discussion, it’s a way to avoid the harder questions by appealing to our natural concern about budget limitations.

So obviously I don’t think this means the expense - any expense, really - should be approved automatically. It does mean the Board should explain why such a comparatively modest expenditure is being treated as a potentially decisive obstacle to a policy supported by substantial research on adolescent sleep.

If the district believes healthier school schedules are important, surely this is the kind of investment that deserves serious consideration rather than dismissal based on budget constraints. In fact, even if the amount needed to get the optimal scheduled were 10x to 20x more it should still be seriously considered - we have to balance priorities, and student rest and optimal learning environments should be among the most critical uses of the school budget.

Why Aren’t We More Seriously Pursuing an Elementary-First Approach?

The scientific research is not especially ambiguous. Major pediatric and sleep-medicine organizations recommend that middle and high schools begin no earlier than 8:30 a.m.

Today, FCPS middle schools generally begin at 7:30 a.m. That is a full hour earlier than the recommended threshold.

The 30-minute-shift might improve matters, but it would leave middle schools starting at 8:00 a.m. An elementary-first approach will address the underlying problem more completely. Leaving any high school or middle school student starting their academic day before 8:30 AM is not a compromise, it’s a rejection of research-based nationally recommended practices - it’s failing our students for no good reason. And pushing elementary school to a later end time is a disservice to our elementary school students and teachers, who already deal with tired students at the end of the school day.

And this is not an untested concept.

Loudoun County already operates a system in which elementary schools start earlier and secondary schools start later. We aren’t talking about some random idea. We can look to our neighboring county for experience that demonstrates that this model is operationally possible in a large Northern Virginia school system.

Of course, Loudoun’s experience also highlights legitimate concerns about very early elementary bus pickups and family satisfaction. Those concerns deserve attention, we should figure out how to solve them not reject the right model because it will take work.

So why hasn’t an elementary-first model received a more sustained, solution-oriented push? Why aren’t we examining variations that reduce excessively early pickups, studying Loudoun’s lessons, and identifying the transportation investments needed to make the approach work?

The elementary-first proposal appears to have been taken off the table without the serious consideration and public debate it deserves. In fact, I would argue that if you aren’t going to do elementary first - and solve the start time problem for upper grade students - you aren’t seriously working on this problem. It appears that the FCPS administration and School Board aren’t seriously working on this problem, they are looking to avoid it.

The Board Should Make the Case, Not Count the Votes

I am not arguing that there is one perfect schedule or that community concerns should be ignored. I am arguing that the Board should approach this as a substantive public-policy decision.

Start with the research. Identify the outcomes we want for students. Evaluate the real operational tradeoffs. Put the costs in context. Use surveys to understand implementation challenges, not to substitute for informed judgment.

Then make a decision and explain it. Their job isn’t to make the public happy, it’s to help the public understand the reasoning behind a decision and see the overall value of that decision.

The Fairfax County School Board has the opportunity to demonstrate thoughtful evidence-based leadership on an issue affecting tens of thousands of students and families.

I hope its members will take that responsibility seriously. We, the residents of Fairfax County, are counting on them to do the hard work required and make the right decisions.

Our students deserve more than the most popular answer to a survey. They deserve the best decision the School Board can make.

Contact The FCPS School Board

We should each come to our own opinion on this issue. But it is also critical we share our thoughts with members of the FCPS School Board. I’m providing a list of the current (NOVEMBER 2026) board members and their email addresses. Please make your voice known.

District / PositionSchool Board MemberEmail Address
BraddockTom Dannan[email protected]
Dranesville (Chair)Robyn Lady[email protected]
FranconiaMarcia St. John-Cunning[email protected]
Hunter MillMelanie K. Meren[email protected]
MasonRicardy Anderson[email protected]
Mount VernonMateo Dunne[email protected]
ProvidenceKarl Frisch[email protected]
SpringfieldSandy Anderson[email protected]
SullySeema Dixit[email protected]
At-Large (Vice Chair)Kyle McDaniel[email protected]
At-LargeRyan McElveen[email protected]
At-LargeIlryong Moon[email protected]